Amy Elizabeth Mayhew

Amy Elizabeth Mayhew

Amy Elizabeth Mayhew

October 22, 1960~November 02, 2021

Amy Mitchell Mayhew, age 61 of Baker, Florida, passed away at Sacred Heart Hospital in Pensacola, Florida, on November 2, 2021.

Amy was born October 2, 1960 at Pineview General Hospital, Valdosta, Georgia, to the late Clinton and Elizabeth “Betty Jane” Mitchell. She, along with her husband Geno, owned and operated “The Gator Cafe” in Baker, Florida.

Amy, the second of four girls, graduated from Hamilton County High School in 1978. She then attended Valdosta State University. Amy spent a part of her life in Guaynabo, Puerto Rico and then returned to Jasper for a short period of time. She later settled in Baker, Florida, after meeting her husband, Geno.

When not assisting Geno managing the cafe, she was either working in her yard, cooking or shopping for treasure finds at estate sales. She had impeccable style and never left her house without looking like a million bucks, much to her sisters’ dismay.

She was preceded in death by her parents, Clinton and Betty Jane Mitchell.

Survivors include her husband, Geno Mayhew; her son, Josh Mayhew: daughters, Gina Mayhew, Leslie, Ashley and Alexandra Sanchez; her three sisters, Cathy Hall, Julie Bedsole and Emily Boswell; and five grandchildren.

A Memorial Service will be held Sunday, November 14, 2021, beginning at 1:00 pm, from the Chapel of Brackney Funeral Service with Pastor David Vanzant officiating. A gathering of family and friends will be held at The Gator Cafe after the service, please bring a covered dish and in Amy style, share good food and memories. The family will receive friends Sunday November 14th from 12-1 pm at the funeral home.

You may leave your condolences at


Brackney Funeral Service 480 East James Lee Boulevard Crestview, FL 32539-2829


Brackney Funeral Service 480 East James Lee Boulevard Crestview, FL 32539-2829


Tony johnson

April 16, 2022, 4:41 pm

Geno, so sorry to hear that Amy passed away. I was unable to attend the service because,I had a heart attack followed by a triple bypass durning that time frame. Sending good vibes your way.

Leave a Condolence

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.